Common Law Marriage vs. Traditional Marriage: Key Differences in Divorce

Marriage
8/15/2024

Marriage, in its various forms, is a legally recognized union that impacts numerous aspects of life, especially regarding separation and divorce. In Texas, couples can enter into a traditional or common-law marriage. While both types of marriages provide specific legal rights and responsibilities, they also have distinct differences, particularly regarding divorce. At Coldwell Bowes, we are committed to helping you understand these differences and navigate the complexities of divorce in Texas. This article will explore the key differences between common law and traditional marriages and their implications for divorce.

What is Common Law Marriage?

Common law, informal marriage, is a legally recognized marriage without a formal ceremony or marriage license. In Texas, couples can establish a common law marriage by meeting specific criteria set by state law. Understanding these criteria is crucial for couples considering or claiming common-law marriage status.

Criteria for Common Law Marriage in Texas

To establish a common law marriage in Texas, couples must meet the following criteria:

  1. Agreement to Marry: Both parties must agree to be married. This agreement can be verbal or written.
  2. Cohabitation: The couple must live together in Texas as husband and wife.
  3. Representation to Others: The couple must represent themselves as married. This can include introducing each other as spouses, filing joint tax returns, or having joint bank accounts.

It is important to note that all three criteria must be met simultaneously for a common-law marriage to be recognized in Texas.

Legal Recognition and Rights

Once established, a common law marriage in Texas is legally equivalent to a traditional marriage. This means common-law spouses have the same legal rights and responsibilities as traditionally married couples. These rights include property rights, spousal support, and inheritance rights. However, proving the existence of a common-law marriage can be challenging, especially in divorce.

Key Differences Between Common Law and Traditional Marriages

While common law and traditional marriages are legally recognized in Texas, they differ significantly. These differences can impact various aspects of the relationship, including the divorce process.

Formation of the Marriage

  • Traditional Marriage: Requires a formal ceremony and a state-issued marriage license.
  • Common Law Marriage: No formal ceremony or marriage license is required. Instead, couples must meet the criteria of agreement, cohabitation, and representation.

Proof of Marriage

  • Traditional Marriage: Easily proven with a marriage certificate.
  • Common Law Marriage: Requires evidence that the criteria for common law marriage have been met. This can include witness testimonies, written agreements, or joint financial documents.

Recognition by Other States

  • Traditional Marriage: Universally recognized by all states.
  • Common Law Marriage: Not recognized by all states. Couples moving from Texas to a state that does not recognize common-law marriage may face legal challenges regarding their marital status.

Ending the Marriage

Both common law and traditional marriages must be legally dissolved through the divorce process. However, the implications and challenges involved can differ based on the type of marriage.

Implications for Divorce

Divorce is a complex process that involves numerous legal considerations, including property division, spousal support, and child custody. The type of marriage—common law or traditional—can significantly impact these aspects.

Property Division

In Texas, property acquired during the marriage is considered community property and is subject to division upon divorce. This rule applies to both common law and traditional marriages. However, proving the existence of a common-law marriage can complicate property division.

Challenges in Common Law Divorce

  • Proving the Marriage: One of the primary challenges in a common law divorce is proving that the marriage existed. This can involve presenting evidence and witness testimonies to establish the marriage.
  • Division of Property: Once the marriage is proven, property division follows the same rules as traditional marriages. Community property is divided equitably, while separate property remains with the original owner.

Spousal Support

Spousal support, also known as alimony, is financial support provided by one spouse to the other after divorce. Eligibility and the amount of spousal support depend on various factors, including the length of the marriage and the spouses' financial needs.

  • Traditional Marriage: Spousal support is more straightforward, with eligibility often based on the duration of the marriage and the spouses' financial situation.
  • Common Law Marriage: Establishing eligibility for spousal support can be more complex due to the need to prove the existence and duration of the marriage.

Child Custody and Support

Child custody and support considerations are similar for common law and traditional marriages. The court's primary concern is the child's best interests, regardless of the parents' marital status.

Critical Considerations for Common Law Divorce

  • Proof of Marriage: Gather evidence to prove the existence of a common law marriage, such as joint financial documents, written agreements, and witness testimonies.
  • Legal Representation: Consult with an experienced family law attorney who understands the complexities of common-law marriage and divorce.
  • Documentation: Keep detailed records of any agreements, financial transactions, and representations made to others about marital status.
  • Child Custody and Support: Focus on the child's best interests, and work with your attorney to establish a fair custody and support arrangement.
  • Spousal Support: Be prepared to present evidence of the marriage duration and financial needs to support a claim for spousal support.

Legal Considerations and Advice

Navigating the legal complexities of divorce, whether from a common law or traditional marriage, requires careful consideration and expert guidance. Understanding the specific legal requirements and implications can help ensure a fair and equitable resolution.

Seeking Legal Advice

Regardless of the type of marriage, seeking legal advice from an experienced family law attorney is crucial. An attorney can help you understand your rights and responsibilities, gather necessary evidence, and represent your interests in court.

Preparing for Divorce

Preparation is critical to a successful divorce process. This includes gathering all relevant documents, understanding your financial situation, and considering the best interests of any children involved.

  • Financial Preparation: Compile financial records, including bank statements, tax returns, and property deeds. Understand your assets and liabilities to facilitate equitable division.
  • Child Custody and Support: Focus on creating a stable and supportive environment for your children. Be prepared to discuss custody arrangements and support needs.
  • Legal Documentation: Ensure all legal documents, such as prenuptial or written agreements regarding common law marriage, are accessible and organized.

Mediation and Negotiation

Mediation or negotiation can help resolve divorce-related issues without prolonged litigation. These alternative dispute resolution methods can be beneficial in reaching amicable agreements on property division, spousal support, and child custody.

  • Mediation: A neutral third party helps facilitate discussions and negotiations between the spouses to reach a mutually agreeable solution.
  • Negotiation: Direct negotiations between the spouses, often with the assistance of their attorneys, can help resolve disputes and reach a settlement.

Conclusion

Understanding the key differences between common law and traditional marriages is essential for navigating the divorce process in Texas. Both types of marriages provide legal rights and responsibilities, but they also come with unique challenges, especially in proving the marriage and dividing property. At Coldwell Bowes, we are dedicated to helping you understand these complexities and achieve a fair and equitable resolution. If you are considering divorce or need assistance with family law matters, contact Coldwell Bowes today for expert legal guidance and support.

Go Back